When your child sleeps in a crib, what’s better than one crib mattress protector? Two crib mattress protectors!
Crib mattress protectors are one of the best inventions ever. Not only do they provide a bit of extra padding between your child and their mattress, but they also make clean ups – even in the middle of the night – much easier.
Crib Mattress Must Haves
As mentioned, it’s not enough to have one crib mattress pad. Your really need a minimum of two on hand. You never know when you’re going to need to make an emergency bedding change. And a third crib mattress protector isn’t the worst idea either.
The essentials of a crib mattress protection pad are as follows:
- they need to be 100% waterproof.
- they need to last through hundreds of cycles through the washer and dryer.
- they must make your life easier. Struggling to change an ill-fitting mattress pad is not what you want to be doing at 3 in the morning.
- they must be non-toxic and made with materials suitable for your child’s sensitive skin.
Now that you know you need at least two mattress pads and you know what the most important things to look for are, let’s check out eight of Amazon’s top rated crib mattress pads.
Share It Now
Best Crib Mattress Pad Reviews
This mattress protector is 100% waterproof, yet it’s breathable which is important for keeping moisture problems to a minimum. The cotton terry cover gives it softness without taking away from the support of the mattress.
None of the materials used include vinyl, PVC, phthalates, or any other toxic chemicals. This product proudly boasts a low chemical emissions stamp of approval. And the quietness guarantee assures your child’s sleep won’t be interrupted by a crunchy sounding mattress protector.
With deep, fitted corners that stay put and machine washablility, SureGuard makes a high quality crib mattress protector that you can buy without worrying about your child’s health and safety.
This three layered protective mattress pad cover provides softness even with a 100% waterproof vinyl middle layer. Soft, quilt-like polyester fleece offers comfort on top while a bottom polyester layer helps eliminate any crinkling noises that might be caused by the waterproof barrier.
The American Baby Company makes their mattress covers so that night time accident clean ups are super simple. After you pull off the sheet and mattress pad, just toss it into the washing machine, then tumble dry on the lowest setting.
The extra-deep corners are reinforced and the entire perimeter of the mattress protector is made with durable elastic. It’s generous size fits standard sized crib and toddler bed mattresses while still giving it a snug and secure fit.
The Carter’s Keep Me Dry quilted crib pad is made from 100% polyester and 100% vinyl which makes a soft crib mattress that is 100% waterproof. However, Carter’s does not use the word “hypoallergenic” in their product description.
The reinforced corners, meant to decrease the chance of tearing, help the protector fit all standard sized crib mattresses snuggly.
The top of the mattress cover is quilted to give a soft, comfortable layer between your sleeping child and the protective waterproof layer.
Last but not least, these mattress pads are machine washable and can be placed in the dryer on the lowest setting.
Some parents have complained about a “chemical-like” smell upon opening the package and Carter’s has indicated that the mattress pad should be washed before using as with everything else you buy that comes close to your child’s skin.
Two things stand out about the ACC Pack N Play crib mattress cover:
- a lifetime warranty from the ACC (Amy Carinn Collection) company;
- this mattress protector fits a Pack N Play portable mattress.
ACC offers a variety of sizes to cover all portables mattresses as well as mattresses up to 7 inches deep. And they guarantee that their mattress protectors won’t shrink. They’ll even send your money back if you’re not completely satisfied with their product.
It sounds to good to be true – a well fitting mattress protector for your Pack N Play. But yes, this mattress pad is also completely waterproof, free of toxins, fits snuggly with it’s extra tight fitting skirt, and it’s durable.
The ACC has tested their mattress protectors and found they easily withstood well over 300 trips through the washer and dryer. While other mattress covers start to pill and fray well before 300 washes, ACC’s covers stayed strong.
- they’re made from bamboo,
- they prevent dust mites from multiplying.
Bamboo is unique in that it’s highly absorbent and quickly pulls moisture away from your baby. It’s also extremely durable and it allows the mattress protector to “breathe” which is important for preventing the growth of bacteria and mold.
This bamboo protector pad is washing machine and dryer safe, unlike some other products made with bamboo.
This two layered mattress protector fits snuggly yet is easy to put on and take off. The top terry cloth layer is quilted and extremely soft. The waterproof layer is made with eco-friendly polyurethane that won’t make noises when your child rolls over in their sleep.
Margaux & May stand behind their crib mattress protector with a lifetime “better than money back” guarantee.
- 100% waterproof without any crinkly sounds,
- phthalate, vinyl, and PVC free,
- the perfect fitted sheet style in the size you need.
Their protective crib mattress covers are easy to remove and put on. They are also machine washable.
Each breathable mattress protector is thin and does not take away from the feel or support of the mattress. The mattress protectors are made with light weight polyester and polyester blended materials to keep your child cool and comfortable.
It’s lifetime warranty insures that your child will be protected from dust mites and bacteria along with spills and stains forever and it’s a good choice for those suffering from allergies.
Swaddlez, the manufacturer, makes these claims about bamboo:
- it is naturally hypoallergenic and anti-bacterial;
- it is environmentally sustainable;
- it is breathable and yet highly absorbent;
- it draws moisture away from baby keeping them comfortable in both summer and winter.
This snug fitting, waterproof crib mattress cover has an extra deep skirt and is ultra soft. You can put it in the washing machine and dryer without worrying about damaging it.
It is also hypoallergenic and offers your child protection against dust mites and bacteria while still being chemical free.
If this bamboo mattress protector doesn’t give your child a better night’s sleep, your purchase is backed by a 100% satisfaction guarantee.
This waterproof crib mattress protector is hypoallergenic and made with super absorbent bamboo that is guaranteed to keep your child comfortable and dry.
The ultra-soft bamboo terry fitted sheet top is quilted to give the mattress cover a blanket-like pad which promotes a better night’s sleep. It’s hypoallergenic nature prevents the growth of dust mites, bacteria, and mold.
The Hello Baby crib mattress cover boasts a waterproof membrane that is also breathable.
This machine washable, dryer friendly protective cover is stain resistant and makes all kinds of clean ups easier. It’s been designed to last through multiple trips through the washer and dryer.
For a Better Night’s Sleep
All of the mattress protectors on this list are excellent choices that protect your crib mattress while also keeping your child comfortable and dry should a wet accident occur.
Since most of the mattress protectors are hypoallergenic and all of them are waterproof, your choice comes down to three main things:
- material selection, and
- All eight mattress protectors have excellent reviews by parents who’ve tried them out, so it doesn’t seem like a big risk to go with the cheapest option.
Three out of the eight mattress protectors are made with bamboo. Some are cotton, others are polyester, and a few companies don’t specify what material their protectors are made of. Some have a thicker, quilted top while others are thin. Most are hypoallergenic and all are non-toxic.
Three of the mattress protector manufacturers offer a lifetime guarantee, one has a ten-year guarantee, and the others don’t specify a guarantee. How long do you expect to be in the crib mattress stage of life?
Whatever mattress protector you choose, be sure to buy at least two. It will make your life just a little bit easier.